Fwd: Edge 350 - Jaron Lanier: The Local-Global Flip, or, "The Lanier Effect"; The "Best of Edge" book series

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: "ashvini v"
Date: Aug 30, 2011 10:09 PM
Subject: Fwd: Edge 350 - Jaron Lanier: The Local-Global Flips, or, "The Lanier Effect"; The "Best of Edge" book series
To:
JUST FANTASTIC.
-------------------------
"What you have now is a system in which the Internet user becomes the product that is being sold to others, and what the product is, is the ability to be manipulated. "
Google has done something that might even be more destructive of the middle class, which is they've said, "Well, since Moore's law makes computation really cheap, let's just give away the computation, but keep the data." And that's a disaster.
... "If we enter into the kind of world that Google likes, the world that Google wants, it's a world where information is copied so much on the Internet that nobody knows where it came from anymore, so there can't be any rights of authorship. However, you need a big search engine to even figure out what it is or find it.

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Edge <editor@edge.org>
Date: Tue, Aug 30, 2011 at 11:01 PM
Subject: Edge 350 - Jaron Lanier: The Local-Global Flip, or, "The Lanier Effect"; The "Best of Edge" book series
To: AV

EDGE.ORG - August 30, 2011
http://www.edge.org
---------------------------------------------------
THE THIRD CULTURE
---------------------------------------------------
"If you aspire to use computer network power to become a global force through shaping the world instead of acting as a local player in an unfathomably large environment, when you make that global flip, you can no longer play the game of advantaging the design of the world to yourself and expect it to be sustainable. The great difficulty of becoming powerful and getting close to a computer network is: Can people learn to forego the temptations, the heroin-like rewards of being able to reform the world to your own advantage in order to instead make something sustainable?"
THE LOCAL-GLOBAL FLIP, OR, "THE LANIER EFFECT"
A Conversations with Jaron Lanier
Introduction by John Brockman
Permalink: http://edge.org/conversation/the-local-global-flip
[John Brockman:] We used to think that information is power and that the personal computer enabled lives. But, according to Jaron Lanier, things changed about ten years ago. He cites Apple, Google, and Walmart as some of the reasons. ... In a freewheeling hour-long conversation, Lanier touches on, and goes beyond the themes he launched in his influential 2006 Edge essay "Digital Maoism: The Hazards of the New Online Collectivism." What he terms "The Local-Global Flip" might be better expressed as "The Lanier Effect". Here's a sampling:
... "The Apple idea is that instead of the personal computer model where people own their own information, and everybody can be a creator as well as a consumer, we're moving towards this iPad, iPhone model where it's not as adequate for media creation as the real media creation tools, and even though you can become a seller over the network, you have to pass through Apple's gate to accept what you do, and your chances of doing well are very small, and it's not a person to person thing, it's a business through a hub, through Apple to others, and it doesn't create a middle class, it creates a new kind of upper class. ... Google has done something that might even be more destructive of the middle class, which is they've said, "Well, since Moore's law makes computation really cheap, let's just give away the computation, but keep the data." And that's a disaster.
... "If we enter into the kind of world that Google likes, the world that Google wants, it's a world where information is copied so much on the Internet that nobody knows where it came from anymore, so there can't be any rights of authorship. However, you need a big search engine to even figure out what it is or find it. They want a lot of chaos that they can have an ability to undo. ... when you have copying on a network, you throw out information because you lose the provenance, and then you need a search engine to figure it out again. That's part of why Google can exist. Ah, the perversity of it all just gets to me.
... "What Wal-Mart recognized is that information is power, and by using network information, you could consolidate extraordinary power, and so have information about what could be made where, when, what could be moved where, when, who would buy what, when for how much? By coalescing all of that, and reducing the unknowns, they were able to globalize their point of view so they were no longer a local player, but they essentially became their own market, and that's what information can do. The use of networks can turn you from a local player in a larger system into your own global system.
... "The reason this breaks is that there's a local-global flip that happens. When you start to use an information network to concentrate information and therefore power, you benefit from a first arrival effect, and from some other common network effects that make it very hard for other people to come and grab your position. And this gets a little detailed, but it was very hard for somebody else to copy Wal-Mart once Wal-Mart had gathered all the information, because once they have the whole world aligned by the information in their server, they created essentially an expense or a risk for anybody to jump out of that system. That was very hard. ... In a similar way, once you are a customer of Google's ad network, the moment that you stop bidding for your keyword, you're guaranteeing that your closest competitor will get it. It's no longer just, "Well, I don't know if I want this slot in the abstract, and who knows if a competitor or some entirely unrelated party will get it." Instead, you have to hold on to your ground because suddenly every decision becomes strategic for you, and immediately. It creates a new kind of glue, or a new kind of stickiness.
... "It can become such a bizarre system. What you have now is a system in which the Internet user becomes the product that is being sold to others, and what the product is, is the ability to be manipulated. It's an anti-liberty system, and I know that the rhetoric around it is very contrary to that. ... What we have to do to create liberty in the future is to monetize more and more instead of monetize less and less, and in particular we have to monetize more and more of what ordinary people do, unless we want to make them into wards of the state. That's the stark choice we have in the long-term." ... MORE

JARON LANIER is a computer scientist, composer, and visual artist. He is the author of YOU ARE NOT A GADGET: A MANIFESTO.
---------------------------------------------------
EDGE Books
---------------------------------------------------
"We'd certainly be better off if everyone sampled the fabulous Edge symposium, which, like the best in science, is modest and daring all at once."
— David Brooks, New York Times column
THE "BEST OF EDGE" BOOK SERIES:
Edited by John Brockman
Permalink: http://edge.org/conversation/the-quotbest-of-edge-quot-book-series
The first two books of the five-book "Best of EDGE" series are now in bookstores and online ....
THE MIND: LEADING SCIENTISTS EXPLORE THE BRAIN, MEMORY, PERSONALITY, AND HAPPINESS
STEVEN PINKER on how the human brain works • MARTIN SELIGMAN on happiness and what it means to live a good life • PHILIP ZIMBARDO on the impact of environment on personality • V.S. RAMACHANDRAN on the question of sef—who "you" are • SIMON BARON-COHEN on the innate differences between boys and girls • GEORGE LAKOFF on the role of the body and brain on difference types of reasoning • ALSON GOPNIK  on why human children are the best learning machines in the universe • JONATHAN HAIDT on the connections between emotions, morality, and religious belief • AND MORE
Amazon: http://amzn.to/ovkvRT  Barnes & Noble: http://bit.ly/pYrRar
CULTURE: LEADING SCIENTISTS EXPLORE SOCIETIES, ART, POWER, AND TECHNOLOGY
JARED DIAMOND on why societies collapse and how we can make better decisions to protect out own future • DENIS DUTTON on the origins or art • DANIEL C. DENNETT on the evolution of cultures • JARON LANIER on the ominous impact of the Internet • NICHOLAS CHRISTAKIS on the structure and rules of social networks, both "real" and online •CLAY SHIRKY and EVGENY MOROZOV on the political reality of the digital era • BRIAN ENO on what culture value • STEWART BRAND on the responsibilities of human power • DOUGLAS RUSHKOFF on the next Renaissance • W. DANIEL HILLIS on the Net as a global "knowledge web" • AND MORE
Amazon: http://amzn.to/pfwI88  Barnes & Noble: http://bit.ly/qgtpn9
About EDGE
"Open-minded, free ranging, intellectually playful ... an unadorned pleasure in curiosity, a collective expression of wonder at the living and inanimate world ... an ongoing and thrilling colloquium."— Ian McEwan in The Telegraph
"Brilliant, essential and addictive. The result of this ambitious venture, for those who have already experienced navigating the web pages of edge.org, is not only brilliant, but addictive. It interprets, it interrogates, it provokes. Each text can be a world in itself." — Publico(Lisbon)
"Edge is the greatest virtual research university in the world ... Deliciously creative ... the variety astonishes ... intellectual skyrockets of stunning brilliance. Nobody in the world is doing what Edge is doing." — Denis Dutton, Founder & Edtior, Arts & Letters Daily
And ... "Fantastically stimulating...It's like the crack cocaine of the thinking world." — BBC Radio 4. "Astounding reading." Boston Globe  — "Splendidly enlightened." The Independent —"An intellectual treasure trove." San Francisco Chronicle —"Audacious and stimulating." La Vanguardia — "Brilliant... a eureka moment at the edge of knowledge." Sunday Times —"Fascinating and provocative reading." The Guardian — "Thoughts to make jaws drop."Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung — "Uplifting ...enthralling." The Mail — A great event in the Anglo-Saxon culture." El Mundo — "Wonderful reading." The Times  — "Strangely addictive."The Telegraph — "The intellectual elite." The  Guardian — "Awesome." Wired "A major force on the intellectual scene in the US."  Irish Times —"Brilliant ... captivating ... overwhelming."Seed Magazine —"A stellar cast of intellectuals." New Scientist —"Brilliant!" The Sunday Times" A running fire of a provocative and fascinating ideas" La Stampa — "Fascinating and thought-provoking ...wonderful, intelligent. "American Scientist —"Thrilling." Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung — "Marvellous … highly recommended." Prospect — "Big, deep and ambitous  ... breathtaking in scope."New Scientist
About The Editor
"A kind of thinker that does not exist in Europe." — La Stampa
---------------------------------------------------
---------------------------------------------------
Edge Foundation, Inc. is a nonprofit private operating foundation under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
----------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------
EDGE.ORG
John Brockman, Editor and Publisher
Russell Weinberger, Associate Publisher
Copyright (c) 2011 by Edge Foundation, Inc.
All Rights Reserved.
Published by Edge Foundation, Inc.,
5 East 59th Street,
New York, NY 10022
----------------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------
---